New York requires workers' compensation for every employer with one or more employees — W-2, part-time, or family. The New York Workers' Compensation Board (WCB) is one of the most administratively strict in the country, and noncompliance triggers steep penalties and potential stop-work orders. Rates are set through the NY Compensation Insurance Rating Board (NYCIRB), and the state runs a competitive market supplemented by the State Insurance Fund (SIF) as insurer of last resort.
50+ carriers shopped · Serving New York contractors · Regulated by NY DFS ↗
Every state regulates commercial insurance differently. Here's what matters for workers' comp in New York.
Unlike many states, New York generally requires coverage even for part-time, seasonal, and unpaid family workers. Owner-exclusion is available for sole proprietors and LLC members with no other employees, but exclusions must be filed with the WCB.
Labor Law §240/241 imposes near-absolute liability on owners and GCs for gravity-related injuries. This makes NY GL and umbrella rates for contractors — especially roofers, framers, and masons — materially higher than adjacent states.
All employers must post WCB-notified forms on the job site. GCs in NY routinely verify sub WC via a WC-4 form or a certificate of insurance naming the state specifically; Certificate of WC Coverage (WC-12) is the state-issued proof.
NY also requires Disability Benefits (DB) insurance — a separate short-term disability fund for off-the-job illness. Often bundled with WC but technically separate; most small contractors need both.
Rates vary meaningfully by state because class codes, litigation climate, medical costs, and regulatory requirements all differ. Here's the New York picture.
NY WC premium rates are among the highest in the Northeast. Roofing class codes can exceed $22 per $100 payroll; inside electrical runs $4-$6; clerical around $0.30. New York has a binding experience-mod factor applied after three years of experience. The state's Scaffold Law (Labor Law §240/241) creates near-absolute liability for elevated-work injuries, which flows into both GL and WC claim severity. Downstate NY (NYC, Nassau, Suffolk) rates run meaningfully higher than upstate due to litigation climate and medical costs.
Core coverage is the same nationwide. New York-specific regulations layer on top of these baseline protections.
Emergency room, surgery, follow-up care, physical therapy, prescriptions, and long-term rehab when a crew member is injured while working. No deductible to the employee.
Partial wage replacement while the injured worker is off the job — typically around 66% of weekly wages, subject to state maximums and waiting periods.
If an injury leads to permanent impairment, the policy pays scheduled benefits based on the body part or percentage loss as defined in the state fee schedule.
Funeral expenses and ongoing benefits to the spouse and dependents if a worker is killed on the job. State statutes govern the benefit structure.
Protects you from tort suits brought by an employee (or the employee's spouse) that fall outside the comp-exclusive remedy. $500K / $500K / $500K is standard baseline.
Carrier handles the whole file — claim intake, medical case management, return-to-work coordination, settlement negotiation, and appeal if contested.
| Factor | Impact | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Class code (trade) | Major | Single biggest driver. Roofing at $15-$25 per $100 payroll; inside electrical around $3-$6; clerical under $1. Your class code IS your premium. |
| Annual payroll | Major | Premium is charged per $100 of payroll. More payroll = more premium, proportionally. |
| Experience mod (ex-mod) | Major | After three years, your historical claim frequency and severity produces an ex-mod that multiplies your premium. 1.00 is neutral; 0.80 gets a 20% discount; 1.30 adds 30%. |
| State | Moderate | States have monopolistic funds (WA, OH, ND, WY) vs. open markets. Rates, assessments, and statutes vary widely. |
| Claims history | Moderate | Five-year loss run determines carrier appetite and pricing. Multiple open indemnity claims narrow the market. |
| Owner inclusion/exclusion | Minor | Including owners adds payroll to the calculation. Excluding them drops it but removes their coverage. |
| Safety program & training | Minor | Formal safety program, OSHA training records, and drug testing can unlock 5-10% credits and move you into standard markets. |
New York-specific questions first, then the general workers' comp questions.
No — a sole proprietor with no employees generally isn't required to carry WC for themselves, and can file an exclusion. But GCs in New York almost always require a WC certificate before sub-contract awarded, which forces many solo contractors to buy a "ghost" policy or sole-proprietor WC anyway.
Labor Law §240/241 imposes strict liability on owners and GCs for height-related injuries. While this is primarily a GL issue, WC claim severity also runs higher in New York because of the overlapping tort exposure — carriers price in the downstream litigation cost.
SIF is a state-run workers' comp carrier that operates as insurer of last resort — contractors unable to get coverage in the private market can go to SIF. Rates through SIF aren't always higher, but service and claim handling differ from private carriers. We shop private markets first and only resort to SIF when that's the right fit.
Every state except Texas requires WC once you have W-2 employees. Even Texas, while technically optional, leaves you exposed to unlimited tort liability if you don't carry it — and most general contractors won't sub to an uninsured shop. If you have even one W-2 employee doing trade work, you need it.
If a 1099 sub carries their own WC and provides a certificate, they don't hit your policy. But if a sub is uninsured and gets hurt on your job, most states make you the statutory employer — meaning the claim falls on your policy. Always collect and verify sub COIs before they start work.
WC premium = (annual payroll ÷ 100) × class rate × experience mod. Rates range from under $1 per $100 for clerical to $25+ for roofing. A $1M payroll general contractor with a 1.00 ex-mod and a mid-range blended class rate typically pays $25,000 – $60,000 per year. Roofers and demolition contractors pay materially more.
After three years of claim history, NCCI (or your state's bureau) calculates an ex-mod — a multiplier applied to your premium. 1.00 is neutral; anything below 1.00 earns you a credit (fewer / smaller claims than peers); anything above 1.00 adds a debit. A 0.80 ex-mod saves 20% of premium; a 1.30 ex-mod costs 30% extra. It's the biggest single lever you can pull over time.
Most states allow sole proprietors, LLC members, and corporate officers to exclude themselves — which drops them from the payroll calculation and lowers premium. But excluded owners have no WC coverage for their own injuries. If you exclude yourself, make sure you carry health insurance and disability coverage to fill the gap.
A ghost WC policy covers a business with no employees (or only excluded owners), purely so you can provide a WC certificate to GCs that require it. It's cheap — often $800-$1,500 per year — and solves the common problem of being uninsurable-by-contract without actually needing coverage.
The going-and-coming rule generally excludes ordinary commuting. But if you're driving between job sites, running an employer errand, or carrying tools to the site as part of the job, the injury is typically covered. Facts matter — each claim gets investigated.
WC covers employee injuries. GL covers third-party claims. They are mutually exclusive. Every contractor needs both, and neither one substitutes for the other. GC contracts almost always require certificates showing both.
A single large claim ages into your ex-mod calculation over three years. Severity hurts, but frequency hurts more — three small claims often raises the ex-mod more than one large one. This is why return-to-work programs and early claim management matter financially even for minor injuries.
Most states require WC for family employees the same as any employee, though some states carve out exemptions for spouses and minor children. Check your state's specific rule — we'll verify at bind.
We place workers' comp for contractors across all 50 states. State-specific pages for the top markets.
Tell us your trade. We send real numbers in 2 hours. No fee. No obligation.